I’m not quite sure how it came up in a Google News alert for cat-related stories, but I just found this article from Marie Claire, an excerpt from a book called Ungrateful Immigrant Daughter that details the way an American woman found out her mom was a Russian mail-order bride.
The woman’s response toward her mother is lacking in compassion, but I don’t know her family dynamics and the title of her book indicates she is at least aware of how she comes off. The one thing I do recognize is the longing to feel normal as the child of an immigrant in an America where normal is a form of social currency. Having the “weird parent” who talks funny, has a “strange” name and unfamiliar customs exposes you to all sorts of torture from other kids, who can be inventively cruel.
The story also reminds me of one of the most bizarre interviews I’d ever conducted during my time as a newspaper reporter.
The guy on the other end of the line pitched it to me as a story about how he was scammed by a foreign temptress, as something other American men should watch out for. I agreed to meet him and hear his story.
He was a mid-level bureaucrat in state government who invited me into a conference room during his lunch break. He was hygienically challenged with visible dandruff, heavy acne, a rumpled button-down shirt and the kind of tie worn by men who view professional sartorial standards as an unavoidable nuisance.
At one point during our conversation he dug a finger into his nose and retrieved a gummy piece of snot. I looked away, embarrassed, but it didn’t even seem to register in his mind.
I’m not sure exactly when I realized he was describing his experience with a mail-order bride, but I will never forget his heavy sigh as he reached into a pocket and retrieved a worn catalog featuring Russian women in their 30s and 40s.
I’d never seen anything like it. The best way I can describe it is somewhere between the print version of a dating site and a grocery store’s weekly circular, with photos of Ukrainian and Russian women dressed to the nines and wearing heavy makeup above their listed stats, requirements for a husband and parody-worthy relationship tropes: enjoying long walks on the beach, sunsets, that sort of thing.



(Above: Not the actual catalog, but it was similar to this.)
“Here,” the man said, pushing the catalog across the table. “You can keep this for your story.”
He paused, took the catalog back, turned to the page featuring his ex-wife, then tore it out carefully before folding it reverently and slipping it into the front breast pocket of his shirt.
I didn’t know what to say as he sat there with a single tear running down his cheek and sniffled. The catalog sat there in front of me and I hesitated to touch it, remembering where this man’s finger had had been a few minutes earlier.
He explained how he had traveled to Moscow with a cohort of American men, then spent the first night on speed dates in a hotel ballroom with women who were desperate to get out of the country, chatting with them under the watchful eyes of burly men with names like Yuri and Artyom.
The second night was spent with a smaller group of women after each of the American men had narrowed down their choices, again chaperoned by taciturn Russian men. The third night was a date with each man’s final pick before agreements were made, contracts signed and the men returned home with a future delivery date for their new wives, as if they’d ordered them off Amazon.
It quickly became clear that the man I was speaking to did not view women as human beings and had little experience with them. He complained about infrequent sex, how much it was costing him to feed and clothe his new bride and her daughter, feeling disrespected, and the many ways in which his fantasy was demolished by reality.
It didn’t take long for his new Russian bride to split. A few months, if I recall. The man went to work one day, came home and found his wife and her daughter gone.
When I got back to the newsroom, my editor stopped me.
“How’d it go with the scam story?”
I didn’t have the heart to tell him the depressing truth and said it just wasn’t particularly compelling or newsworthy. I spiked the potential story from my calendar, tossed the mail order bride catalog in a bin far from my desk when no one was looking, and made a beeline for the bathroom to scrub the hell out of my hands.

I will never understand how people fall for scams like this. The worst being giving your money away to someone you never even met.
LikeLike
Those are the so-called “pig butchering” scams out of China and Myanmar. They’re brutal, playing out over months to take the victim for everything they have.
LikeLike
3 jobs back a co-worker of mine went to the Philippines to get a mail order bride and never came back. The lore around the office was that someone had called the company trying to arrange a ransom for him. All these years later I ran into a person who worked in HR at that place at that time and the truth is that someone in the Philippines did call the company but they weren’t expecting them to pay for their employee, they were just trying to find contact information for his family so they could pay.
LikeLike
Who did he think he was, Art Bell?! Haha.
I imagine his family was not receptive to the ransom.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Truly shocking. The fact that the catalogue was printed and not on an app suggests it was a few years ago, but I guess this sort of thing still happens. How does our society bring up some men to think this way?
LikeLike
Indeed, it was well into the online dating era. Not sure why they were still using print, but I’ll never forget the catalog and the man’s notes scribbled in the margins.
It’s probably even more popular now with the Ukraine war, both sides targeting civilian infrastructure and Russia’s economy on life support. Lots of people want out.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yuck
LikeLike
That about sums it up, yeah.
LikeLike
I’ve always wondered about this: Do men who are willing to pay for a mail-order bride realize that the other person doesn’t like them? I mean, how can they feel good about themselves knowing they had to pay for someone to be their wife… that’s really sad.
LikeLike
I’ve wondered the same thing. It’s like those guys who pester and pester women to go out with them, who think “no” is just a temporary precursor to “yes.”
LikeLike