NY Sanctuary Founder, As Many As 100 Cats Feared Dead In ‘Suspicious’ Fire

Chris Arsenault ran back into the fire in an attempt to save more cats and never reemerged.

A man who founded a cat sanctuary to honor the legacy of his deceased son was killed, along with some 100 of the cats he cared for, in a raging fire Monday morning.

Christopher Arsenault, 65, lived on the premises of the Happy Cat sanctuary in Medford, along with about 300 cats he’d saved from euthanasia, dangerous situations and difficult lives as strays.

Firefighters were dispatched a few minutes after 7 am and it took them an hour and 20 minutes to bring the powerful blaze under control. Arsenault was able to get out of the main structure on the Suffolk County, Long Island, compound, but dashed back in to save more of his cats, according to neighbors who witnessed the fire.

Chris Arsenault at Happy Cat sanctuary. Credit: Happy Cat Sanctuary

The Suffolk County homicide and arson investigation squads are assigned to the case, Suffolk police Chief of Detectives  William Doherty told the New  York Post.

However, it can take weeks for lab results from the state police crime lab in Albany, and fire investigators will need to comb through the remains of the ruined structure and the rubble to find a point of origin.

“It’s too early in the investigation to determine any cause,” Doherty told the Post.

The grounds and facilities at Happy Cat sanctuary were meticulously maintained, but that did not stop some in the community from complaining about the existence of the sanctuary.

Arsenault “vowed to take the unwanted, discarded, homeless [cats], the ones that people were going to euthanize, he refused and he took them into his sanctuary, sometimes for no money at all,” Lisa Jaeger, a local cat rescuer who worked with Arsenault, told NBC New York. “He started the sanctuary [in 2007]. This was his life. He gave his life to save these cats.”

The sanctuary’s Facebook page was flooded with an outpouring of grief on Monday from people who knew and supported Arsenault.

“He was always so concerned about each and every single cat he had in his care. Didn’t matter how many… they were all his babies,” one distraught woman wrote. “To think he literally lost his life trying to save them breaks my heart and makes all the sense in the world that he would never leave them behind.”

Local rescuers and the county SPCA were trying to corral the surviving 200 cats on Monday. Some fled the grounds during the fire and remained unaccounted for, while others remained close to the destroyed sanctuary despite the chaos and the significant amount of activity from first responders.

Despite his efforts, Arsenault was the subject of a harassment campaign on social media from neighbors and a small group of people who alleged Arsenault wasn’t properly caring for cats. There’s no evidence to back up those claims, and Happy Cat has not been the subject of any violations.

A petition on Change.org posted last year demanded a stop to the alleged harassment of Arsenault by neighbors and a local code enforcement officer. It garnered 28,665 verified signatures.

Despite locals standing up for him, Arsenault had found a piece of property in upstate New York and was preparing to move his cats and sanctuary to that location.

John DeBacker, who participates in local trap, neuter, return (TNR) efforts, referenced the push back against Happy Cat in a post about the fire on Monday.

“Despite being harassed for months, he continued to fight for the cats,” the post read, “and I truly hope everyone can screenshot posts from one of the groups that has been harassing him in case arson is connected.”

An outdoor area at Happy Cat sanctuary. Credit: Happy Cat Sanctuary

It’s important to note that there is no evidence connecting any of the critics to the fire, authorities have not commented on the source of the fire, and any speculation about the cause is just that: speculation. It’s also important to emphasize that just because police homicide and arson squads are investigating an incident does not mean either of those crimes has taken place. Authorities won’t know anything for sure until they can thoroughly investigate the fire scene and get lab reports on evidence.

Arsenault himself said he felt compelled to respond to critics last month in a video he posted to Youtube.

“The audacity of these people to call Happy Cat sanctuary a hoarding situation, to be claiming that we’re committing animal abuse and animal neglect,” he said “The cats that I see…these are cats that are out there and have nowhere to go. These are cats that are suffering out there. And this is where sanctuaries come in … Right now [the critics are] just taking a big handful of spaghetti, and they’re just throwing it up against the wall to see what sticks to come after Happy Cat sanctuary.”

20 thoughts on “NY Sanctuary Founder, As Many As 100 Cats Feared Dead In ‘Suspicious’ Fire”

    1. My ex called me before this post. When we were together we visited Chris many times. This was not a hoarding situation. My ex- boyfriend, retired FDNY, cried very few times while i have known him. This was one of them.

      Liked by 2 people

      Reply

      2. I looked at many photos on the sanctuary’s website and Facebook page, watched several videos, and saw nothing but well cared-for cats living in a great environment built for them, which was kept immaculately clean by Chris Arsenault. I’m sure keeping things tidy with 300 cats is a tall task, but the facility was beautifully kept, which reflects how much Chris cared.

        Liked by 2 people

      3. Didn’t really finish the other comment … As others have said, I really hope it wasn’t arson. If neighbors were that bothered by it, would they have preferred the cats were in their yards?! Looks like a win-win for the neighborhood to me.

        Liked by 1 person

    2. Hi Leah. You could eat off the floor at this place. Since Chris trusted me i sent people to him to adopt cat,or cats,from Happy Cat. He said he trusted me because very shy cats came to me after couple of hours. My friends adopted Peaches from there for thier cat who needed a companion. Needless to say they were devastated.

      Liked by 1 person

      Reply

  3. Even as a writer, I cannot come up with the word that means more than heartbreak, more than sadness, more than grief. But that’s what I’m feeling, that and a general hopelessness for a world in which such a thing as this can happen. I hope to find it was not arson, because that would be beyond cruel.

    Thank you for presenting the information with such kindness.

    Liked by 2 people

    Reply

    1. It’s disturbing how many indifferent people there are and worse, how many cruel ones. I will say some prayers for Mr. Arsenault and his kitty friends. This is an unhappy situation.

      Liked by 1 person

      Reply

    2. Thanks, Molly. You’re absolutely right, it’s difficult to describe how upsetting this situation is. I hope there’s justice, if it’s a situation that calls for it, and that the sanctuary can continue in some form.

      Liked by 2 people

      Reply

      1. Without speculating on what could have caused this particular fire, there are a hundred things that could cause a fire like this, from electrical problems, to someone carelessly tossing a cigarette in the wrong place, to defective equipment, to arson.

        Fire investigation is an especially difficult job, and fire science is a very weird thing. I don’t envy the job those guys have, but I’m glad there are people who are capable of doing it.

        Liked by 2 people

  5. This is a tragedy. Not only are the man and many cats dead, the sanctuary is finished. Of course “some” neighbors had problems with the place – what a surprise. This is absolutely devastating.

    Liked by 3 people

    Reply

    1. Without speculating on what happened here (sorry, I sound like a broken record), this is why I keep hammering home the point that demonizing cats, or any other animal for that matter, has real world consequences, from promoting insane legislation and culling attempts, to the depraved motivations of people who poison food left for strays and ferals.

      Liked by 2 people

      Reply

  6. Did not read the whole thing but not shocked as what my ex-boyfriend me about the people in Long Island. He has a small colony of fixed cats ON HIS PROPERTY and he noticed cans of tuna. He suspects it was laced with poison because he saw some green shit on it. He told me a certain group, MAGAts he calls them, like to shoot feral cats not only in Long Island but Staten Island. Guess why cops refuse to do anything?

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply
  9. Pingback: Investigators Rule Sanctuary Fire ‘Not Suspicious’ As Vets And Volunteers Treat 200 Surviving Cats – Pain In The Bud

Leave a comment